In the decade that GayCalgary has been reviewing shows at Stage West the quality of the productions have always been top notch. Whether their popular and fun music reviews like British Invasion or One Hit Wonders, revivals of Broadway classics like Jesus Christ Superstar or earlier this year’s award winning Chicago, or a non-musical show, they have always had stellar talent on stage and high production value from the sets to the live music.

That is where the frustration lies in I Love You Because, playing until November 10th. It is a fantastic production - with incredibly talented actors - of a so-so show. It has its moments that verge on great, such as the fantastic number That’s What’s Gonna Happen, but there are not enough of them.

There is definite chemistry between Canadian Idol alumni Steffi D who plays photographer Marcy, and the adorable Daniel Abrahamson who plays Austin, in the modern twist of Pride and Prejudice. They are both likeable despite their quirks, and their adventures on the dating scene, along with those of Jeff (Jay Davis) and Diana (Blair Irwin) are experiences many of us have had. Somehow despite the familiarity it doesn’t resonate, perhaps because aspects of it are clichéd and explored in every romantic comedy. Justin Bott and Lindsey Frasier round out the cast playing baristas, bartenders and a Chinese food waiter - different people the 4 main characters interact with on another Saturday night in New York.

I Love You Because is an enjoyable night out, with great food (the white chocolate lemon cheesecake is amazing) exceptional singing and a likeable cast. I can’t exactly put my finger on what’s missing, but like dating itself, you have some that are fun for a night but who you wouldn’t call back.