Why Be Happy When You Could Be Normal?, by Jeanette
Winterson. Grove Press, 224 pages, $25 hardcover.
More than a quarter-century after her searing
autobiographical novel, Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit, Winterson revisits
the bleak childhood depicted in that story – and, in this seething memoir,
suggests that life in the home of her evangelical adoptive mother was even
bleaker, more hellish and more violent, and that reality was far worse than
fiction. The novel "was a book I could live with...the other one is too
painful," she writes now, suggesting that, from the perspective of years – and
after a nervous breakdown (following the end of a six-year relationship) and an
attempted suicide – there’s a truer story to be told about her early years.
After revisiting her past, Winterson recounts a no less harrowing present, in
which a "savage lunatic" is both desperate to be loved while repelling the
women who would love her, and in which an adult searching for lost mother-love
becomes obsessed with searching for her birth mother. Their eventual reunion
turned out to be lukewarm comfort; it didn’t fill the author’s emotional gap.
Enter, Night, by Michael Rowe. Chizine Publications, 420
pages, $15.95 paper.
Rowe’s outstanding first novel – after editing horror
anthologies and penning well-crafted essays – is hard to categorize. There’s a
vampire, but it’s not just a classic vampire novel (though blood is sucked and
holy water splashes). There’s the mystery of a murder to be solved, but it’s
not a traditional detective story. Both gay pride and gay shame figure in the
plot, but it’s way more than a gay read. Set in a small northern Ontario town
in 1972, Rowe’s characters include Christina Parr, destitute after the death of
her husband, Jack, one-time scion of mining wealth but long estranged from his
truly wicked mother, from whom Christina has sought shelter; her feisty
daughter, Morgan, who befriends 12-year-old loner Finn, the hero of the tale;
and her queer brother-in-law Jeremy, who like his brother Jack fled Parr’s
Landing after bedding a buddy. And the vampire? He’s the embodiment of a 17th-century
Catholic priest whose evil spirit, trapped in an archeological site near town,
bathes the streets of Parr’s Landing with horrific blood in this terrific
story.
Growing Up Delicious, by Marianne Banks. Bella Books, 232
pages, $15.95 paper.
Life in the small, mean town of Delicious was miserable for
young Jennifer. Her mother was a tyrannical clean freak, her father was mostly
drunk (though always caring) and her first lover, Ruthie, the preacher’s
daughter, abandoned her to marry a man. The town’s notorious tomboy, she was
forever the odd girl. And her misery only worsened when, at her sweetheart’s
wedding, she tried to drown the preacher. A quarter century later, Jennifer,
content in a relationship with a sensible woman, is called home by her
hysterical (and hysterically straight) sister, Dorothy, who found their mother
hanging from a beam in the family barn, an apparent suicide. Though reluctant
to return, she finds comfort in the welcome of crusty gas-station owner Rosie
and of Ina Lewinski, whose home was a safe harbor for young Jennifer – but
disdain from others. Banks’ debut is a broad-stroke satire of homophobic
attitudes, small-town hypocrisy, religious intolerance and – in a serious back
story that meshes well with the novel’s dominant humorous tone – repressed
shame and closely held secrets.
For the Ferryman: A Personal History, by Charles
Silverstein. Chelsea Station Editions, 340 pages, $20 paper.
Readers might have expected more in this memoir about
psychiatrist Silverstein’s heroic, historic effort in the early 1970s to remove
homosexuality as a mental illness from his profession’s diagnostic manual. Or
about his authorship in 1977 (with Edmund White) of the groundbreaking (and, in
some places, eyebrow-raising) how-to tome, The Joy of Gay Sex. Both of those
high points in the author’s memorable life are covered, of course, though
briefly, as are his pre-gay years and the horror of the early AIDS years. But
Silverstein focuses mostly on his tempestuous 20-year relationship with William
Bory, a stunningly handsome 21-year-old with daddy issues when they met
(Silverstein was 15 years his senior). Their love was true and deep, but not
always a bed of roses: Bory was sexually alluring and intellectually brilliant
but emotionally mercurial and, for years, an addict who stole from his partner.
This searing memoir’s depiction of their years together, at once adoring and
despairing, is testament to the enduring power of love, even as it addresses
both men’s frailties and flaws.
Featured Excerpt
William and I were perfect mirror images of each other’s
needs. He was looking for a father to take care of him, while I, in the role of
an idealized father, searched for my "son," myself, to love as a substitute for
the father who had abandoned me. In a psychological sense, it was a marriage
made in heaven, a perfect union of two gay men in search of their phantom
fathers. When I made William happy, I felt vindicated; when I failed, I was sure
that I was culpable for his discomfort. And I continued to believe this
tortured reasoning until the day he died.
-from For the Ferryman, by Charles Silverstein
Footnotes
If the Lambda Literary Awards are the queer Oscars,
is there a LGBT equivalent to the Golden Globes? Not really – the Publishing
Triangle Awards, to be announced in the next couple of months, are just as
prestigious, if not as high profile, as the Lammys, whose winners will be named
in early June. And there’s a certain cachet attached, as well, to the winners
of the Stonewall Awards, selected by members of the American Library
Association’s Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Transgender
Round Table (GLBTRT), which were announced in late January. The fiction award
went to Wayne Hoffman’s Sweet Like Sugar , and runner-up "honor" titles are
The Temperamentals, a play by Jon Marans; Remembrance of Things I Forgot,
by Bob Smith; and Annabel, by Kathleen Winter. The nonfiction award was a
tie: Hide/Seek: Difference and Desire in American Portraiture, by Jonathan D.
Katz and David C. Ward; and A Queer History of the United States, by Michael
Bronski. Runners-up are Nina Here Nor There: My Journey Beyond Gender, by
Nick Krieger; Persistence: All Ways Butch and Femme, edited by Ivan E. Coyote
and Zena Sharman; and Seeing Gertrude Stein: Five Stories, by Wanda M. Corn
and Tirza True Latimer. The young adult award went to Putting Makeup on the
Fat Boy, by Bil Wright, while there were four runners-up: Pink, by Lili
Wilkinson; With or Without You, by Brian Farrey; a + e 4ever, drawn and
written by Ilike Merey; and Money Boy, by Paul Yee.
Richard Labonte has been reading, editing, selling, and writing about queer literature since the mid-’70s.